|
|
|
|
Muslim's Comments
Warning: This page contains foul language. The reason I decided not to censor these emails is to show what Islam does to people and what category of people are devout Muslims.
Usman Aslam <ajmalamjad2000@yahoo.com> Hello Mr, I don't believe you were a muslim, a muslim cannot leave islam, because every muslim knows very well what is islam and every muslim know that this not just a religion this is whole way of passing life.you may be from other religion barking at islam and you may not be alone but will be a group of people. you have made this story that you were a muslim and you left islam to attract the attention ,son of a bitch If you are so much sure about your fucking ideas then come in front of the world and do not hide yourself behind the web. but you know the result of this and you son of a bitch why don't you change you name if you hate islam you bastered. How many muslims are leaving islam , no one, but thousands of others are joining islam and this is due to its ideas and teachings. but very sorry to say you can do nothing, nothing is in your control even you cannot come in front of the world, fuck you
Jan, 23, 2002 justin gardiner <joshewan_man@start.com.au> I had a look at your site. It's ....quite interesting... While I don't refute (can't) a lot of what you say about the Q'uran, I see the "method in your madness". So I am going to set you a little challenge, I am going to challenge you to debate on the Torah, and show that there are just as many vile statements in it.Vile, putrid and racial statements, "hate" statements. Furthermore (after seeing your little link about Palestinians celebrating in the streets) I am going to comprehensively demolish you mentally, verbally and unequivocally on your occupation of "The West Bank" and Gaza strips. I see what you are doing, and I am smart enough to understand your vile intentions. Furthermore, please don't even entertain any thought whatsoever of ignoring this email, lest I make this very public. The web is a great disseminator of information. However, having said this, you seem to be an honourable person, and I believe you will keep your word. So I would like to set some rules, I would also wish (should you accept my challenge) that you have some input into this process. I look forward to your reply. Sincerely,
Justin Gardiner
Dear Justin, If you are interested in absurdities of the Bible see this link. http://www.geocities.com/freethoughtmecca/blamegame.html There are hundreds of books written on this subject. If you want to see the cruelties in the Bible just read the book of Joshua.
Azzadeen ZAVI" <ee1128@elec.qmul.ac.uk> Hi
there. I
am commenting from London, These
is lack of information on some points. You can comment any thing you
think but please i suggest you to comment/add on your website that Muslims
can't be a muslim untl they have a belief in Jesus, Ibraham, moses
and all other prophets and musllms habe to belief in all books as well
to become a muslim. So
if you analyse this point it will lead your mentallity to impartiality
of Islam. So
the other things jesus was hanged by Jewsih not by Muslim and at that time
the Islam did not exist. About
jihad,that is necessary in islam and not towards the innocent non-beleivers. So
i might decide about your thinking as a psycho/abnormal who waste his time
in a useless web or you might make it to earn some money from some agencies
as well because that is easy way to earn money. so
do mail me i will reply you regards
to all people you know there Mr
A . Zavi
chairshot@cwcom.net On Wed, 23 January 2002, "andy lord" wrote: Why do you
only hate Muslims and not Christianity or Judaism, both of which are as hateful
as Islam? Is that damn specific enough for you? andy lord First of all I do not hate Muslims but Islam. Please note that there is a huge difference. Muslims are my relatives and friends. I love them, not hate them. I could not care less about Christianity, Judaism or any other religion. However these religions do are not advocating hate today. Sure there are a lot of violent stories in the Old Testament but neither the Jews nor the Christians are killing people in the name of God. They are just false religions. They are also useless religions but they are not dangerous religions. Islam is false is useless but it is also dangerous. Regards Ali Sina On Sat, 19 January 2002, "andy lord" wrote: Are you really a doctor, or is it just a facade perfectly designed to give yourself some authority where really you have If, as you claim, you are against ALL religion, then why have you just made a site denigrating Islam, when almost everything you say (the Earth beng flat etc.)can also be applied to Christianity and Judaism The fact that you have not done may say something about why you receive death threats, when in your mind you're just spreading "Love, man"
Yes I am really a doctor but I do not use my since it might give the impression that I have some sort of authority. My field of study has nothing to do with religion anyway and as far as the subject I deal with in my site is concerned I am a layman. Some people still refer to me as Doctor but I prefer Mr. I find all religions spurious and useless, but I do not fight against useless beliefs. They are useless for me but they obviously are not for those who still believe in them. So I respect their choice to believe and do not wish to decry what they hold dear to their hearts. The reason I want to eradicate Islam is because it is a cult that inseminates hate. What happened in Sep 11 was not a misunderstanding of Islam. It was perfectly inspired by the teachings of Quran. As long as Islam is alive, more sadistic murders such as that will happen. Today Muslim extremists are ready willing and soon will be able to ship atomic bombs to the shores of many Western cities and kill millions of innocent people. We cannot stop terrorism as long as we do not eradiate the philosophy that motivates it. Osama bin Laden is not the problem. He is the product of the problem. The problem is Islam and the teachings of Quran. The world must wake up and deal with Islam seriously. The main responsibility is on the shoulders of Muslims themselves. All those Muslims who truly believe in unity of human kind must read the Quran to realize what kind of murderous mad man was Muhammad and stop following this crazy man. Muhammad like Hitler, Stalin, Komeini, Saddam Hussein or Osama was also a narcissist that fooled people using religion as the pretext to establish his dominance on them. It is time for Muslims to wake up. As long as a billion people follow this mad man blindly and without reading and understanding what he did and say, Muslim extremists will get their affirmation and will continue applying the teachings of Quran and carnages such as that of Sep 11 will continue to happen. I call upon all the Muslim who love the humanity and want peace to read the Qruan and denounce Islam publicly. We can fight against terrorism only when we withdraw our moral support of the terrorists. This will happen when millions of Muslims announce their severance from Islam. Regards
Ali Sina
"shahzad sarwar" <shahzadsb@yahoo.com> Salam, No comments on your site. I would like to know following things about ur life. 1. Age , education , current job. 2. Your life , family , their impact on u. 2. Your religious Background in detial. From
where u got religious education in any form,
and at which level. Hope, You u will not mind it personal. You have expressed
your personal views so loudly to all world, then why not this. Do publish it on your site. Looking to hear from u soon. May Allah bless u. Regards, ssb
Dear Shahzad, I have expressed my personal VIEWS but what you ask are personal information. This site is not about me. It is about Islam and its impact on humanity. No one cares who is Ali Sina nor they should. I have not made any claims for myself nor I will. I am just one individual raising the question, shouldn't we study Islam on our own and not rely on what we were told? May be we find the real Islam to be quite different from what we think it is.
Jan, 17,2002 Haseen Pari" <haseenpari@hotmail.com> You know what? You are a unbalanced and mentally sick person … get yourself treated before you land up in trouble. I wish Allah shows you the right path. That’s all I can say to you.
Jan, 17, 2002 Yasir MUshtaq" <decents_noparking@hotmail.com> hey stupied listen what u think of ur self. y ur againnst Muslims is any reason if u think that Islam is not good religon then teell me which Religon is good. and what u think that u will stay all time in this world for ur whole life Nah sonn u will die or killed by me then u will what will Allah done with u in Hell. And don't forget that we r afraid of u Nah if u have power then give me the ans of few questions Allah has said in Quran that if u think that ur true then bring a Book(Holy Quran) like this or make any one verse like this and one thing more if u think that ur true then try to change it. Quran is protected by Allah and u can;t change it. If u think that ur true then ist show me that u have change
Quran as u have change others books not u but those who has changed r also like
u. so i accept ur challenge and Allah is with me. Ist answer my queestions then
try to say something against Muslims. WWW.DECENTS.cjb.net
-- "B. Real" <benzondubz@hotmail.com> wrote: downplay the september 11 event, this will cause hate
towards muslims if you really love the human race like you say dont be the cause
of hatred against muslims, muslims are people like everyone else Downplay the Sep 11 event? Are you
kidding? 3000 innocent people died senselessly and you want me to downplay it.
Sr. Why don’t you wake up to the reality that you are responsible for those
deaths? Yes I hold you and all those who think Islam is a true religion
responsible for all the killings that the Muslim extremists commit in the name
of Islam. Islam instructs its followers to hate the non-Muslims and eulogizes
killing and being killed in the name of Allah. All those who support Islam in
fact express their agreement with whatever Islam teaches. Therefore they are
responsible for the killings perpetrated by Muslim terrorists. The terrorists
are the real Muslims. As long as you support Islam you are endorsing terrorism. To defuse hate I suggest let us get rid of the hate mongering doctrines. This is the way to bring about the unity of human kind not through deceits and perpetuation of lies. Regards
Dear Ali Sinn, AISHA KHAN.
Alan Goldas <alangodlas@yahoo.com> Jan, 13, 2002 Please post this up in the section "Muslim comments" Exposing Golshan (The man who calls himself Mr Ali Sina) The irony behind Mr Ali Sina is he says “I have read the
Qur'an and then the Hadith several times with a free mind and I saw just the
opposite picture what man y Muslim scholars claim”. He claims to be a
“free-thinker”, “rational” and “unbiased” in everyway yet when
inviting people to witness his so-called genius – out of context Quranic
verses! he says “take my word for it” and “trust in me, I was there” How
criminally insane! A large number of his visitors are inherent ignorant
Americans, whom ever sine 911 have
rushed to educate themselves about Islam, foreign affairs and the Middle East.
His readers after witnessing a few crimes committed in the name of Islam are
only too willing to listen to his views, since Mr Sina is probably the one
person whom they could relate o. The question that should be asked is: Are Mr
Sina’s readers also free-thinkers, unbiased and rational? The militant extremists use Islam as a tool to manipulate the
poor and ignorant to gain political power. Has Mr Sina not adopted the same
brain-washing technique, which feeds the imagination of the unlearnt?
Mr Sina says: “I receive many mails from angry Muslims
who ask me to remove this site. if you disagree with this site and want me to
remove it, I invite you to disprove my accusations against Muhammad and Islam.
If you can show that what I say is unfounded I promise to remove this site not
before confessing that I was wrong and Islam is a true religion.”
The truth of the matter is Mr Sina receives hundreds of emails every
month from outraged Muslims, Christians, Jews and Hindu’s. Some of these
people although do not buy the Islamic faith, have lots of respect and
admiration for it. Mr Sina’s continuous overconfidence takes a hold of him
right here. His challenge “If you can show that what I say is unfounded I
promise to remove this site” is a game which he thinks he is playing with all
those who take the time and effort to bother with this insanity. On those
occasions where a particular Brother or Sister takes the opportunity to address
him, he brings forward the letters on his website. It does not bother Mr Sina
what our educated Brothers and Sisters have to say, since Mr Sina’s only
objective is to deny and lie. Not on one occasion has Mr Sina bothered to
investigate the claims as some people ask him to. For example on one occasion a
particular brother wrote “The verses you quote are out of context, one is
nonexistent!”. Mr Sina overlooked the claim and instead resorted to
highlighting another aspect of this brothers letter which Mr Sina felt proved
just how violent all Muslims are! Islamic scholars, from the West and East and Christian
historians regularly take the time to prove him wrong…..people who have
devoted grey beards to a life time of research on Islam and religion. People who
are versed with History, Theology and its workings around religion regularly
prove Mr Sina’s claims to be unfounded. Mr Sina has no interest in listening
to the words of those who are in the field. Does he seriously think out of 100
letters addressing his madness all are wrong! That is the bigheaded attitude he
has adopted. All those reading his scandalous diatribe do themselves total
injustice. Ignorance breeds ignorance, hatred breeds hatred, injustice breeds
terrorism. Oh and Mr Sina, you say Ghandi was your greatest teacher
yet did you know Ghandi was a great admirer of the Prophet Mohammed? How much
integrity do you hold Mr Sina?
Dear Mr. Goldas, Sir, instead of all these cheap talks
and accusations wasn’t it easier to prove me wrong? Of course not! You cannot
prove me wrong and no other Muslim can. Islam is a false doctrine and Muhammad
was a liar. In the absence of truth, all you can do is ranting. As for Gandhi, I admire the man for
his non-violence method but I do not regard anyone infallible. I do not follow
anyone blindly. This is the difference between a freethinker and a believer. A
freethinker relies on his or her own reasoning and recognizes the truth no
matter where that truth may be. A believer surrenders his mind to someone else
and stops thinking. He expects to be guided by someone else. If his guru or
prophet tells him that night is bright and day is dark he accepts it without
questioning. Gandhi was a politician. He had to
play the political game of appeasement to avoid major social tumults and blood
sheds. I think if I was in his place I would have done the same thing. The funny thing
is that Muslims really believe it when politicians and public figures such as
Gandhi, Prince Charles, President Bush and PM Tony Blair say, “Islam is a
religion of peace”. If they really believed in this nonsense they would
convert to Islam. These people know
nothing of Islam, they have not read the Quran, and they are simply playing
their political game. Islam is NOT a religion of peace. I have demonstrated that
throughout my site. If you say I am mistaken just prove me wrong. You know that
unlike Islamic sites I do publish the emails of my opponents. So please take
advantage of my commitment to freedom of expression, (a thing that Muslims only
demand for themselves but never give it to others) and prove me wrong.
azman shah" <x_putera@yahoo.com> i am from malaysia...may Allah forgive u on what u have done....but i wanna make some correction..the picture that shows palestinian celebrates the wtc tragedy is a not a real photo. that photo is taken when they celebrates something..i dont remember but it had been confirm by europe newspaper journalist....anyway...pls dont say something bad about islam...the christanity that convert into muslim never talking bad about their old religion...so please....stop what u have done..i dont know whether u r muslim or what..but what can i say...u never know about islam...remember...waht u have said will affect u...
TZ ME" <asificare@hotmail.com> Thu, 10 Jan 2002 dear who
ever you are, i
personnaly take the responsibilty of attacking the WTC and the pentagon. lets
see you do something about that! i ordered those 19 heros (may Allah bless them
with all his rewards) to carry out the attacks. you can go ask them about me
masterminding the whole adventure. anyway,
don`t despair. atleast you can make a great holywood movie on the topic. seriously,
i was over-joyed with what happened on 9/11. did you see all those people
jumping off the top floors, idiots! now, were they thinking rationally ? sometimes
i think, what was the use of their being in the world? i`m sure they`d be better
off in hell-fire. and hey ! you dont need to cry for them, thinking
rationally, it doesn`t effect them (or the world) one single bit.
people will soon forget who those 3000 bastrads were, only the 19 hijackers
will be remembered for carrying out the largest terrorist attack in the world. (don`t
get to conclusion right now, read ahead, i`ll justify those blessed attacks
rationally to you). about
muslims... well, what wrong in killing people ? everyone has done that ever
since the first human. one who kills more is always remembered as a great
conqueror in history. that`s a fact, isn`t it ? terrorism is cool and its
getting more and more popularity. everywhere in the world people like to solve
their problems violently, whether they say so openly or not, its human nature.
terrorism is an easy solution to big problems. tell me is there any other method
by which nations can solve their disputes ? can you give me a few example from
history ? Allah,
knowing this fact, as he is the creator, has encouraged muslims to fight non-beleivers,
till they are eliminated from the face of the earth, only then can all problems
be solved. if we don`t finish off non-muslims and hypocrats, we will always have
differences and problems will remain the way they are. therefore,
i don`t see any problem with killing of non-believer and also muslims who work
for non-beleivers and also those muslims who don`t resort to violence the way
God wants us to. violence
is not a negative term, it only means to remove a problem by completly
eliminating its root. (by any method).... i had a friend on chat who used to
call himself a rationalist and had ideas similar as yours. we debated for
years and in the end, he had to admit that humans are made violent, they are
made to terrorise others in order to survive, survival of the fittest is a
natural phenomena. (according to that bastard darwin, he was a bastrad,
literally, so don`t argue about that). all great personalities from history
were great terrorists. they were fundamentalists too, becoz they never changed
their opinion/ideas and got what they set their minds for (at any cost). the
other so-called famous people were either mad-scientists or pimps. who cares
about them? notice how
violet ideas are spreading amoung the youngsters esp. in the west. the fact
is, teenagers are attracted to violence and inshallah a day will come when all
the problems in the world will be solved just the way nature wants them to be
solved. and yes
Allah is a harsh God, no doubt about that. some muslims have portrayed him as a
gentle and peaceful God. well, he does have those characteristics too but he is
also the avenger and the punisher and only he can disciple humans. if we dont
follow him, he will for sure send us to hell, he is not at all merciful with
those who don`t follow his rulings. he is happy with those who perform kitaal
(killings) in his path and do jehad. jehad = holy war against non-beleivers.
Mashallah ! what a beautiful verse, everytime i read the verses of the Quran
about jehad, my faith gets stronger and my believe in God as the ultimate truth
solidifies. jehad represent the truth about human nature. and history is a
witness to that. in the
end, lets pray that a day will come when this cycle of violence will end, and
only one type of people remain who have no differences amoung themselves. i hope
you get my point. do think about it sometime. violence is a reality, terrorism
is human nature, and hence islam is rational. Mohsin
Khan Baltimore,
Maryland PS: in the
end, please allow me to say this to the families of those who lost relatives and
friends in the 9/11 attacks .... may God send more and more miseries to you, May
he intensify your pain (by the way, i got that from the bible), may he burn your
relatives and friends in hell for ever, may he send more aeroplanes crashing
into the US. may he send a meteorite at washington, may your grief and
subsequent problems greatly increase. Ameeeeeeeen ! some
people will ask, am i mad ? answer: ofcource not ! as a staunch beleiver in
rationalism, its my duty to project things exactly as they are.
Jan, 7, 2002 Mr. Ali Sina just gone through your website .... seriously ... i think ur being more
offensive towards Islamic teachings .....
as you said urself that your criticism is about all the religions ..... but
in your website .. you constantly criticize Islam and prophet Muhammad .....
mostly using refences from hadith .... rather than shedding some lighting on
Christianity, Zionism and hindus ..... and performing some comparative analysis
.... anyway ..... you have the right to do whatever you want to ... and Islam does
teaches us to be free thinkers ... so if ur free thought have miss guided you
.... then may Allah have mercy on your soul ..... and yes ... please dont try to spoon feed the young brains by constantly
quoting the contradictory statements in the teachings of Islam and thus,
becoming biased ... let them be REAL free thinkers and also include all the
noble teachings of Islam too ....... so they can make up their own minds .... i have so much to say ..... but perhaps another time :) jamshid mahmood
I have already answered your question in the main page of this site. All religions are man made and useless. The world would be much better without them. But I do not want to be the champion of truth. If these spurious beliefs make people happy, let them be. I do not fight against lies. I fight against hate. I do not write against Islam because it is ridicules, stupid and pure nonsense. Some people prefer falsehood to truth and are naturally stupid. You cannot force them to be intelligent, rational or sensible. You cannot criticize a pig for not having a long neck like giraffe, says a Chinese proverb. I fight against Islam because it promotes hate. No other religion promotes as much hate as Islam does. Islam breads terrorists. Islam violates the rights of all human beings including its own followers. Islam is an insult to womanhood, Islam means cruelty even to animals. Islam is a danger to peace. The growth of Islam would CERTAINLY increase the chances of a third world war. I think fighting against Islam is the most sacred duty of anyone who cares about humanity, peace and unity. Christians, Jews and Hindus have been fighting against the lies of their own religions for the last 200 years. These religions are now just charity organizations. They no more sway the power that they had once. But Islam has killed all its dissidents and very few dared to confront it. Today we can confront it.
ALI (or who ever you are) Your
thinking has got nothing to be termed as "rational thinking" All
you tried is to prove islam a false religion, but none of your points are valid
enough to proove that.remember, quran is the only holy book free of alterations,
clearly indicating that it is a true holy book and its verses are revealed by
allah, the only lord of the universe. Even during the early days of islam many
tried to present verses like those but none of them succeded. You
also said that the prophet muhammed (p.b.u.h) used to kill his openents, infact
the prophet (p.b.u.h) was the source on enlighment for the whole world his deeds
were the real golden deeds of humanity. The victory of makkah is a clear
indication of it, when he gave aman to all his enemies. Once on a occasion
kafirs stoned him and he was very much hurt, one of his followers asked him to
pray bad words for those kafirs but he replied that i am send in this world as
the messenger of peace not as the messenger of brutality. You pointed jihad as
an act of terrorism, but when one reads through the real islamic codes for jihad
he can then easily get through your lies. Islam didnt even ask its fighters to
cut any trees or to damage any crops. This is the true islam, is there anything
bad in it? The whole site of yours is agaisnt the islam but you still call
yourself as a muslim. (one of your replies shows that) actualy what you aim at
is to work upon the brains of muslim youths perhaps thats why i got your url at
some local dalnet channel. Your
ideas are haphazard and havent really got anything in it.all of your site speaks
against islam and muslims but wwhat about the jews killing innocnet palestinians?
Even when the palestinians try to defend themselves they are termed as terorists??
What is india doing with innocent kashmiri muslims?? Their masacre has become a
universal truth but when they fight against it which is even lawful according to
your international laws, they are called terrorists. Why?? It
is only because of the truth that islam has become the fastest growing relegion
of the whole world even if you blindly link muslims with the incidents of the
trade tower. I
dont know wether or not you will reply me but i am eveready to debate you for
the matter. Allah-o-akber. From Usman
mustafa syed Dear Usman Mustafa Syed Thank
you for your email. But there is nothing there in that I have not answered
several times in my site. I am afraid you just have to read few pages. Regards Ali Sina
"ABU_ REEM" <abu__reem@hotmail.com> what r u living for? i mean ur goal in this life? how long time u gonna live? after leaving this life(which i hope), where u ganna be? have any clu? if u r a humanistic, so u should feel sorry for ur self!!! i just want to say, if muslims r bothering u, i advice u to go hell..coz i hear there is no single muslim there... bad for u...may allah burn u now and later animal...animal is better
hi, I read your advertizment in one of my channels on DALnet. I looked at the site and above all, i had 2 questions: 1: Do you really consider yourself as honest ? or is the web site just there to capture the weak minds ? I am asking this very seriously, so dont think i am trying to be sarcastic or something. I can tell the difference between someone who wants to expose the truth, and someone who uses partial truths to spread disbelief and misinformation. The contents of the web site prove you to be the later one, your response will tell me. 2: What is your current belief ? I probably have less time than you, so our communication will be very slow, but I'll try, if you do.
Waiting, Haris I did not place any ad in DALnet. I visited this site after you mentioned it and did not understand what is it about. Here is my answers to your questions: Yes I do consider myself a very honest person. I man be wrong but I do not lie. No I do not expect weak minds accept
me. Weak minds need religions. They can never be freethinkers. I am trying to
shed some light on a subject that has been a taboo for 1400 years. Those who
tempted this before me were killed and their books burned. But I have a powerful
tool at my disposition, which is the Internet. I believe I will have more
success than my predecessors. What I say definitely is for strong minds. No
sissy can handle it. Now you accuse me of spreading
“partial truth” and misinformation but you did not say where I was
misinforming. I issued a challenge that should anyone disprove me I will remove
my site from the Net. Can you do that or you are just good at rhetoric? As for my current belief I have none.
I do not believe in anything. I think beliefs are for people with “weak
minds”. I question, I investigate, I reason, I think and above all I doubt but
I do not believe. .
Jan, 4, 2002 Amir isabeygi <amirisabeygi@yahoo.com Well dear sir, It is absolutely silly and unfair to generalize and accuse the whole Islamic ideology because of the actions taken by a couple of people.You have to know that countries or particular nations do not represent Islamic ideology. I, as an Iranian muslim(A PROUD MUSLIM) do not agree with your ideas.Presumably, you were heavily influenced and persuade by the external forces ,particularly by the one-sided western media.ISLAM is an undeniable part of Iranian culture.I do pray, and I do implement the precepts of my holy religion and I am proud of that unlike you. Shame on you. Khajalat bakash agha .. NOTE: NOT ALL IRANIANS ARE LIKE THIS MAN. IRANIANS ,IN GENERAL DO IMPLEMENT THE PRECEPTS OF ISLAM.THIS PERSON IS A WORTHLESS CREATURE. Bee Adaab , khoda tora beeyamorze
Amir Radmanash
Jan 4. 2002 shahram eisabeygi <shahram@ottawa.com Ali, I have visited your God damn website and the more I read the more I got
angry .I do have the desire to kill you right now. Khoda marged ra bede Ensha-Allah die die and die
Jan 4, 2002 "shah amir" <amir_shah@hotmail.com> Ali, You are a disgrace to Iranians.May God's curse be upon you , and may your
beloved ones suffer from God's curse.I hate you and I mean that. Shame on you you, son of a bitch.
Dec 31, 2001 doggb187@hotmail.com
Thank
you. May peace be upon you.
- Bill
Noble
aahmad1@sympatico.ca ali sina?
"A L I" <servitra@hotmail.com> Dear Ali Sinn, I went through your site. I dont find anything wrong with your mind processes, but
yes. you have not investigated enough. Spend a week with me, and I will prove it to you. Anyone who questions Muhammad and his teachings is welcome
to stay with me and EXPERIENCE all that they deny. Do reply, Ali You are welcome to prove the truth of Islam by email. I prefer to debate through the Internet. I find in this way I can live longer. But thanks for the invitation.
Ali, I practice Islam for the
following: To Define the Human Mind Know my Origin Know My destination I am very skeptical and
question everything. I have seen and observed the world around me and I realized
that what DOES need to be defines is the self. What is the SELF? How do you
define the human being? What is death? forget about practice of Islam, tell me
the things I have asked. Can you? If you fail to answer the
above, then the only thing you have to offer is good English and an ability to
write. Many people have that. It doesn't mean that we get impressed by them. The logic that you have developed against Islam can also be applied to you. One more thing, come and
stay with me for one week. That's my challenge. You will be protected, I can
promise you that. Just give me one week of your life. I don't want to prove you
wrong, I want to prove my own belief right. Its more for myself than you
honestly. Ali Shah Dear Mr. Ali Shah, Whether I can prove to you what is self or not it in no ways mean that Islam is a true paradigm. The definition of self is a philosophical argument that is beyond this site. I may one day write my views on this subject, but this site is not about me and my views. This site is about Islam and whether it has answers to any of human questions. What is the answer of Islam? That man is a slave of a deity who created this world to worship him and if man fails to fulfill his duty that deity will punish him forever. This is the thesis of Islam. Well my friend as I explained in my response to Bakkah this is the most stupid thesis. Therefore Islam has answers that are ridiculous. Would you rather believe in something stupid? As for expending my last week of life with you, I truly am grateful for the offer. But as I said before I prefer to debate on line through email. I personally would like to take care of my safety rather than bothering good people like you for that. You say that you guarantee that I will be protected. However since the Prophet that you follow was in the habit of assassinating his opponents in the middle of the night, I tend not to trust the followers of such a man. Ali Sina
15 Dec 2001 Hello i am sending you
this e-mail to comment about ur site. I know millions of people like you.
Trying to blame islam for your own insecuritys. Twisting the words of the
Quran so that you can get your one minute of fame. I just wanted to point
out that maybe if you took time out of your busy schedule of hatered to read the
WHOLE verse or surah and not just one line you would understand it. You
see people like you are the real sickos and terrorists in this world. You
cant find any one to blame for all the things gone wrong. So you point it
at the easiest target Islam. Now i am sure taht you have never seen the
pictures of the Palestinian People mourning and lighting candels for the victims
of 9-11. That is because you dont care to see the real story you care only
to see the side you want to. Your just another one of those people that
bring fith to this earth. Another supporter of the killers. I am
sure you love Ariel Sharon because he killed 40,000 lebanese muslims during the
time he was defense minister. See what you are doing is wrong. You
dont see TRUE mislims attacking women and killing innocent people. There
is a quote in the quran that says If you kill one person it is as if you
have killed all of man kind but if u save a life it is as if you have saved all
of man kind. So just some food for thought and may allah guide you in the
right path. Salaamwalikum(peace be
with you)
Dec. 9, 2001 Subject: Do you really think you are a free thinker ? First of all, you claim to be a free thinker, but you really are a hater. You are narrow-minded. You are very limited in the way you evaluate the events around you and in the ways you relate something to the other. I support your right to have opinions and express them freely. But I don't agree with you claiming Islam=Hate.
Dec. 9, 2001 Shaikh Hamid" <CYBERSAMMYX@prodigy.net> These sites look to me to be maintained by anti muslim elements,like satanic verses,you cannot fool muslims Please
Dec. 8, 2001 Subject: COMMENT ON THIS EMAIL THEN "ALI".......IF U CAN. HELLO
"ALI", SOMEONE WHO AINT A BIG FAN OF ISLAM (LIKE U )TOLD ME ABOUT UR
WEBSITE. I THINK U HAVE PROBABLY MADE UP THE OMMENTS THAT "MUSLIMS"
MADE, AND I THINK U R A FRAUD (AND A LIAR). U PROBABLY MADE UP THE FACT THAT UR
WERE AN EX MUSLIM JUST TO CONVINCE PPLE TO TO HATE ISLAM. WOT A STUPID PLAN. i KNOW and CAN SEE how u have twisted pples words to give
them a answer. u also JUST PICKED little bits out of the Quran and TWISED THEIR
FULL MEANINGS. I AM NOT GOING TO SWEAR AT U BUT I AINT AT ALL PLEASED WIV
UR FALSE OPINIONS. GET A LIFE-OH sorry u dont know the meaning of life. i BET
U MADE UP THE VVIEWS OF PPLE WHO"AGREED WIV YA" LOL how sad and
pathetic. I TOOK MY time emailing u bcos i thought i might let u add
my comments to pple who r true muslims. just face it - u r a loser. u said
somewhhere that DUMB ppple r muslims LOL EXCUSE ME!!!!!!!!!!! we know u r
dumb fool and i BET U KNOW THAT TOO! do u know that pple like u r decribed in the Quran? yes u r
if u have READ THAT PART! We muslims r safe bcos we r warned already about
alot of things, Islam is the safest, cleanest, and also the RIGHT
religion for mankind. it can be universal. i already know about the beliefs of Islam and i know wots
right and wots wrong, but U R TRULY lost, and the evil and worst thing is u WANT
TO BE. U ALSO SOUND EVIL, Islam is NOT evil at all.
Dec. 7, 2001 U were naver a true muslim.
For u are a cowerd who thinks that just because u have a muslim name and say
that u are muslim that u are well u are very wrong. No i do not think that the
9/11 boming was right, but all the suffering of the muslim people in palistine
right? U have gotten used to america and the lafe style, but remember even
if u enjoy the life here u are not imorta and well answer to allah one day.
eyad" <eyad@moh.gov.jo> Bee ware of what u are eating somone going to fuck ur and put the boisen in ur
food
"Talha Shahid" <talhagold@hotmail.com> Dear person,
When it comes to punishment Allah has actually proven to be impotent. That is why he asked you Muslims to do all the killings in his name. If Allah could punish his enemies why he ordered Muslims to do Jihad and fight in his name? Why Muhammad sent assassins to deal with his opponents? Why Muslims are encouraged to be terrorists? This certainly proves to anyone who has a grain of intelligence that Allah is powerless to punish his enemies in this world and therefore the punishment of the other world is also a lie to scare ignorant people. Who wants to worship such maniac god anyway? If there is a god s/he must be the god of love not of vengeance and terror. If Allah really exist he must be devil who is desperate to be worshipped by men. The real maker of this vast universe wouldn't care if anyone worshipped him or not. As long as people live decent lives not hurting each other he would be happy.
Dec 4, 2001 Salman Azhar <sazhar@yahoo.com> I was forwarded a link to your site, and thought I would share some views with you, in peace. Firstly, you have every right to your opinion and to promote it using whatever means you see fit. Secondly, given your indisposition and the value of your time, and mine, there is no point us wasting it in a debate. Thirdly, it is true that there is a lot of brutality committed in the name of religion all over the world, and that is one thing that hasn't changed. However, the root cause of all these have been basic territorial, monetary, or strategic, and religion has been used to motivate masses as has been, to a lesser extent, nationalism and other forces. Fourthly, your site, and your mission, could be served better with a more unbiased representation of world views so that it is in synchronization with freedom of faith and the message of peace. Peace out! ++SA
hello Ali if that is ur name, i believe u r wrong about Islam. u dont make sense, and u have only picked out little bits from the Quran. that doesn’t make sense bcos u dont understand the meaning if u dont read the WHOLE Quran. Do u even know wot the Quran claims, how it was put togeter and wot its background is? U clearly dont. well u r a predujice person, bcos u sound like a extremist or fanatic evrytime u write something which uve misunderstood. U said in one of the debates that muslims sound like that.. but the truth is u r the one who has alot of hate in urself.
Dec. 02, 2001 "Aamir Malik" <aamir_m@hotmail.com> Read
a few articles on your site. One
is disillusioned. Refutation of religion on the basis of what 'translators' have
made of the quran is unfair. There are over a dozen of translations of Quran. All of them by Muslims. Can you tell us why all these Muslim translators translate the Quran to make it look an intolerant book? However, I do not read a translation of Quran. I read the Quran in Arabic and use a translation just to make sure I do not miss anything. I assure you the original version of Quran is much more harsher than its translations. The translators of Quran have tried their best to soften many of the very violent passages of Quran. The articles are filled with quotations of the quran that are out of context. The Explanations of the Ayat have not been followed up either - without regard to arabic or those that were present ie the people of the time so that the context can be acertained. It is non-scholarly and mob rousing. If you really want to do some service to Islam, you must effectively decipher the good in it from its evil - not reject it outright. I have no desire to do any service to Islam. I want to eradicate it. There is nothing good in Islam. It is all evil. Muhammad claimed to be the messenger of God and that everything he said is the word of God. If there is one evil in it then that is proof that he was an impostor. I have found thousands of things that are wrong in Islam so there is no doubt in my mind that Muhammad was an impostor and not a messenger of God. Moreover if we are the ones who have to sieve between the good and the bad of a book then we are superior to the author of that book. In such a case that book cannot be a book of guidance. As for perceived good things in Quran let me tell you that even Hitler said many things that were good. That is why millions of Germans were fooled and believed in him. Every criminal, even the most heinous serial killer sometimes says things that are good. If you find a verse or two in Quran that you think they are okay, this is no proof that Muhammad was a messenger of God. The Freedom to think can be taken superficially and one can say what one wants - or it may be taken to great heights like Iqbal did or maybe ghazzali? Whichever way, however your articles are proving to be the skimmings of out-of-context quotations for mob arousal! aamir malik The great minds of Islamic world were Zakaria Razi, Omar Khayyan and Bu Ali Sinai. These people did not believe in Islam or Quran. Iqbal and Ghazali were not freethinkers. They were religious thinkers. Religious thinking is not freethinking. Ali Sina
"fareeda ahmed" < lida68@hotmail.com> MR.ALI SINA,YOU BASTARD, SON OF A BITCH. THE DEVIL
HIMSELF.
Dec. 01, 2001 "Mujahid Alonto" <alonto@hotmail.com> Whoever you are or whatever you are, what your telling me does not even bother me. YOu can keep your materialistic ideas. What thing for sure, America will fall together with their kafir allies. By the way, you don't have to answer back, I'll delete it anyway. La'natallahu alay! (May the curse of Allah be upon you)
Noon Noon <ntd1948@yahoo.com> You are not a free thinker, you are a free demon. All your stupid hateful interpretations of Islam do not convince any smart person. Feel free to be with the ignorant and the racist. All of the arguments that you posted to back your accusations failed to do so. Any person with logic and a bit of intelligence can see very easily that you do not make any sense. Enjoy the company of the hateful, racist and ignorant people. .
Ahmed Abdulkarim <ahmad@emirates.net.ae> ALI, ALLAH SELECT HIS PEOPLE, I AM SURE YOU ARE NOT ON
THE LIST. I THINK YOU NEED TO SEE A GOOD DOCTOR TO STRAITEN YOU UP AS I FIND YOU
OUT OF TRACK. WHICH WILL ONLY TAKE YOU TO HELL INSHALLAH. MY BEST WISHES
For
a best understanding of Islam like a religion of Peace, you can visit the
website: aail.org , ahmadiyya.org , and ask yours questions about the true
Islam. No Sir. for the best
understanding of Quran all you have to do is read the Quran.
"Mohamed Mehdi" <scarletrogue@hotmail.com> In the
name of God the most Gracious, the most Merciful Thanks for the offer to debate but no thanks. I believe I already have a good grasp of the depth of your logic. Ali
Sina
Nov. 27, 2001 "MO ^The Man^" <b0rnwild@hotmail.com> Get
a life,u talking about haterd?
Nov, 25, 2001 bidir haveez
< bhaveez@yahoo.com> 1-Reading your false stuff made me bealive in Islam even
more , much more. 2-leave your site or take it off .. Allah will guide his
servants to the right path and inshallah i am one of them. 3-you will be limited to the false information you starve
yourself into.. and you feel good thinking its new ... its not .. you don't harm
Allah in anyway....and when you know your wrong it will be late.. in GREAT PAIN.
4-Only Muslims care....care alot.... and beware. 5-change your name from Ali to something else like kafir.
Nov, 25, 2001 "deja vu" <deja_vu786@hotmail.com> Ali
sin –
Answer:
11/22/2001 "Me" <snoop83@optushome.com.au I think its really sad on how you miss interprate the Quaran , I have
muslim friends and i have red the english version of the Quaran , and what you
are saying is utter bullshit , please grow up or get a life or what ever and
leave the muslims alone . May The Lord Crusify you , you are a shame to all
religions. This one is pretending to be a Christian, :-)
11/21/2001 sajjad shah" <drsahib@hotmail.com> You bloddy bull shit have u ever ever study the Islam and
its undoubt prove as "HOLY QURAN". Before giving answers to your
baseless question, I challenge you to make 2 Quranic
Verses ONLY. If you think that by pasting such photographs which indeep
it reveals that that WTC terrorism was made by ISRAEL Govenment. You bloody fool
should know that at the time of collision, all
4000 israelis were absent at same time from WTC tower.
Dead people contained all religious people except JEWS.WHY?
WHY? WHY? You people are the worshipper of MONEY that by writing Hi
Fi you want to get attention of other people in the world and banner
advertisements. If you have studied HOLY QURAN then you have also read it that
people like you will live at the last level of HELL. Islam
does not need to accept your challenges beacuse such type of question were asked
by our Prophet (PBUH), then ONE & ONLY ALLAH quated in
QURAN, "BEFORE ASKING SUCH QUESTIONS
YOU HAVE TO OBSERVE YOUR OWN GROWTH FROM BIRTH TO COMPLETE MAN". Man its easy to make obligations but you will soonly know
this effect when your eyes get completly shut off. So its better to remove this
site immediately otherwise you will observe your punish soon. Man think about your death that what will happen after
death when no one will be able to help you even your loving mother and etc etc. MAY ALLAH GIVE YOU SUCH SENSE THAT YOU CAN BE ABLE TO
ACCEPT ISLAM AND LIVE IN PEACE AFTER DEATH. The above just demonstrates how shamelessly Muslims
can lie.. Islam is a religion built on lies, deceit and treason, This is
the proof. They commit the murder and blame the victims. In 1978 they closed the
doors of a movie theater and burned 500 people live in Abadan, Iran then said it
was the Shah who did it and thus inaugurated their bloody Islamic
Revolution. See the answer to the above claim in this website http://www.geocities.com/freethoughtmecca/blamegame.html For a full story on this hoax made by Muslims see this article. http://slate.msn.com/?id=116813
11/21/2001 found your website rather boring and didnt see any intelligible evidence of your ridiculous claims. how do you know muslims start such ridiculous rumors? and why are you so anti-islam. usually to give something so much attention and passion towards something you have to LOVE IT>>>>>>>>>>>>> masha allah.....
you claim to be free thinkers..this is a joke..you are as corrupt as the mullahas in Iran..if fact i know why the iranians in this country and in iran are such hypocrits..it is in your culture...see..muslims in iran are not muslims..they support anti muslims causes all over the world..and the iranians in america are as confused as the ones in iran...and why is that every iranian woman i have met is a whore? Dear Jay, If instead of visiting only brothels you visited more respectable places such as universities, hospitals and law offices you'll see that the percentage of Iranian women who are professors, doctors and lawyers are higher than any other ethic group. Iranians have seen the real face of Islam and are waking up. Iran will be the first country that will adopt secularism and since throughout the history Iran has been the trendsetter in the Middle East soon the neighboring countries will follow suit. This is indeed the beginning of the end of Islam and the dawn of a new day of liberation for all Islamic countries. Ali Sina
"Mujtaba
Ali" < mujtaba16@hotmail.com> i laugh at your foolishness and retardness of your minds.
"Rational Thinking," "Free Thinkers" what kind of rational
thinking do you do? Defaming a religion, thats outright stereotyping. no sane
person would call that rational thinking. Bite your tongues and burn in your
rage for u cannot handle the truth. your falsehood has only strengthened my
resolve to fight ignorance. the most powerful man on the planet, the U.S.
president, respects and reveres islam. in fact he reads the Qur'an along with
his bible. September 11 is responsible
for this miracle; no Muslim would have ever imagined the U.S. president
reading and quoting positively from the Qur'an. this shows u clearly, God's plan
is infinite and his plan never waivers to spread Islam, even to the leader of
the most amoral nation on the globe.
Nov. 18, 2001 This email shows how the brain of Muslims function "sherif" <ssadek@sympatico.ca> Do you want to destroy Islam, to express hatred or to
express your envy? I just simply encourage you to do whatever you can, because
God protects this religion. All earth is turning to Islam, and sorry no one can
prevent that. Moslems are
increasing everyday, Moslems are migrating to west more and more, people in the
west are diminishing in number, their reproduction is very low but Moslems are
not, Septempter 11 pushed the whole world to know about Islam, many are
asking and many are turning Moslems .."which by the way is
an emphasis to truth words narrated by our prophet". You are obviously analyzing qura'an as an
ignorant, you don't know what the occasion in which the verses are
mentioned, or what other verses that override it, so the people who hired you
should look for better candidate. By the way, just a
demonstration of your ignorance, you motioned the Mohamed(SAW) didn't split the
moon, you don't know that the people who went to the moon reported that
the moon went through splitting before. There are hundred of mistakes there, but as a true thinker,
and not a TOILET THINKER, when I find one error in whatever I read, like
the previous one, I just discard to look for another, because it is sufficient
for evaluating the writer. By the way, are you a Christian who pays some money to
reserve a place in heaven, or
a Jewish who believes that Jewish scholars' orders must be obeyed by God, or
a person worshiping cows and drinking its urine, Or
a person worshiping Buzza who was eating human wastes Or
a TOILET THINKER
After seeing his email published here this Gentleman sent me another note: Few points that indicates more about how muslim
brain functions and how they see another relegions, by the way those points are dedicated to your USA fans:- Specific contradictions in the books of the Jews: This is my response to him: If you are really interested in Biblical
errancies you may like to take a look at this link. http://members.aol.com/ckbloomfld/index.html The point is that the Christians and the Jews have found out the errors of their respective religions. They talk about it and instead of following those books literally like we Muslims, they uses those books as a pretext to be good and to love their fellow human being. The New Testament is full of errors, but there are no inhumane teachings therein. You cannot possibly follow the New Testament and commit murders and acts of terrorism. On the other hand if you do not commit murders and acts of terrorism you are just a lukewarm Muslim. Quran demands you to kill the unbelievers and promote Islam through Jihad. The Taliban, Bin Laden, Muhammed Atta are the real Muslims, while Mother Teresa is the real Christian. The difference is in the spirit of the teachings. Otherwise both of Christianity and Islam are equally erroneous. But I rather have people follow a false doctrine that brings their goodness out than one that makes them terrorists. You can measure the effect of these teachings in the real life. In the West where people follow Christianity, Judaism or don't follow them, even in places where people follow Hinduism or Buddhism people are advancing, they civilization is marching forward. But look what is happening in Islamic countries. We are going backward. We are literally marching against the history. We are entering the age of barbarism. It is time that we Muslims do the same with our outdated and primitive belief. Why not analyze Islam under the light of reason? I just receive a letter from a Jew.
His name is Keith . See how everyone is waking
up? It’s time that we wake up too. When we all leave these false beliefs that
foment nothing but hate among us, all humanity will become united. At least we would leave behind the main cause of disunity and hate. By the way you may like to read this correspondence. http://www.faithfreedom.org/iranusa.htm There is a reference to your comments. Thank you for writing it. Regards, Your "toilet thinking" friend ;-) Ali Sina
Nov. 17, 2001 LISTEN YOU WEIRDO WE DON'T NEED MIRACLES TO PROVE THE EXISTINCE OF ALLAH ............YOU SHOULD KNOW THAT YOUR WHOLE EXISTENCE IS A MIRACLE OF ALLAH .........AND YOU SHOULD BE THANKFULL OF THAT............BY THE WAY YOU'RE JUST IGNORANT
Nov. 17, 2001 HAVE SEEN MANY THINGS WRONG WITH URE SITE.....FOR INSTANCE ADOPTION IS ALLOWED U JUST CANNOT CLAIM THE CHILD AS YOUR OWN BLOOD CHILD....ANOTHER THING WITH AISHA HE CONSUMATED HIS MARRIGE WITH HER WHEN SHE WAS A TEENAGER, AND HE MARRIED HER TO LOOK AFTER HER FOR AND OLD MAN WHO WAS DYING....AND ALSO MAYBE THE MOST UN-TRUE IS THE SLAVE AND MAID GIRLS....I LAUGHED MY WAY THROUGH READING THAT IT IS VERY VERY VERY VERY FALSE
"Amina Teslima al Jerrahi" <nur@mail.internet.com.mx> It's really something valuable for minds like yours without a clue who dwell in the dullest surface to have the same space and opportunity to speak out your thoughts as those who have been gifted with luminous minds capable of a depth that is foreign to yours. Eventhough your opinions only spread and feed ignorance, which is so easy to do, count on me to defend your freedom to express yourself as you are doing no matter how far in delusion, how lost and vicious your mind has gotten. Amina,
Dear Amina Yes indeed it is amazing! For 1400
years you burned our books, imprisoned us, tortured us and killed us; now you
can’t. Isn’t this amazing! As for defending my right to express myself freely, don't bother. I am free whether you defend it or not. Please go and defend Dr. Younus Sheikh in Pakistan who is now awaiting his death sentence for saying Muhammad was not a Muslim before receiving the revelation. Please go an defend the Qadianis in Pakistan, the Baha'is in Iran, the Hindus in Afghanistan, the Copts in Egypt, the Christians in Sudan and other minorities in Islamic countries. Ali
alaa fuad d <f7778200@emirates.net.ae> DO you know some thing you are soo poor man. iam waitting the Day After to see you in the middle of Hellfire. soooooooooo poooooooooor Man.
I DONT THINK ITS ANY OF UR BIZNESS WHAT PEOPLE CHOOSE THIER RELIGION 2 BE STOP TRYIN 2 GET PEOPLE 2 CHANGE AND STOP DISSIN ON US MUSLIMS ONCE UR MUSLIM WE AINT CHANGIN IT OKKK NO ONE THATS MUSLIM WANTS 2 CHANGE OK WE HAPPY WIT WHAT WE ARE AND NO ONE IS DISSIN ON UR RELIGION B/C BELIEVE ME FROM WHAT I HEAR OTHER RELIGIONS ARE WACK OKK BYYYYE THANKS ALOOOTT AND STOP BEIN SO IMMATURE TELLIN EVERY 1 WHAT 2 DO BC NO 1 WANTS 2 HEAR WHAT U GOT 2 SAY GOODBYE
Rehman A <A.Rehman@rhul.ac.uk> you attack
islam because you don't accept it, you do this because you're |
